Why We Aren't Reporting AI Search Rankings Yet (And Why That Could Soon Change)

SEO
AI is changing how people find businesses online

AI is changing how people find businesses online, and naturally, business owners want to know whether they're showing up when someone asks ChatGPT for a recommendation. If someone asks an AI platform to recommend a web designer, a local counsellor or a business offering a particular service, wouldn't you want to know whether your company is being mentioned?

We certainly would!

There are already plenty of companies offering tools that promise to measure your visibility in AI search. Some even provide rankings, percentages and comparisons with your competitors. And while those reports can look impressive, there's something important to understand about the numbers behind them.

Much of today's AI search visibility reporting is still based on estimates.

That's one of the reasons we haven't started including those statistics in our monthly reports at IA Creative. But some exciting developments are underway, and we're already exploring what they could mean for our clients.


Why AI Search Reporting Is Different From Google

When we measure how your website performs in Google Search, we have access to established reporting tools that provide information about impressions, clicks, search queries and website traffic. That gives us a useful picture of how people are finding your business and interacting with your website.

AI search is a little different.

When someone asks ChatGPT or another AI platform to recommend a business, the answer can change depending on how the question is asked, what information is available and the context of the conversation. Unlike a traditional Google search, there isn't always a consistent list of results where businesses appear in a predictable order.

So how are companies measuring AI search visibility?

Many reporting tools ask AI platforms a collection of sample questions, record which businesses appear in the responses and use those results to calculate visibility scores. For example, a tool might ask ChatGPT to recommend web design companies that specialize in Squarespace websites in Kelowna using several different questions, then report how often IA Creative appears.

That's useful information for identifying patterns and understanding how a business might be represented in AI-generated answers. But it doesn't tell us how many real customers asked those questions or how often the business appeared in actual conversations.

And that's where things get a little tricky.


 Why We're Holding Off on Adding AI Rankings to Your Reports

We want the information in your monthly reports to be meaningful and something you can confidently use to understand how your marketing is performing.

If a report tells you that your business has a 40% AI visibility score, that sounds pretty impressive. But what does it actually mean? In many cases, it means your business appeared in 40% of the sample questions tested by that particular reporting tool. It doesn't mean 40% of ChatGPT users searching for your services saw your business.

That's a pretty important difference!

Now, this doesn't mean these tools have no value. We're interested in what they can tell us and some already offer useful insights into how AI platforms describe businesses and which competitors appear alongside them.

We can also track certain real interactions, such as identifiable visits to your website from AI platforms. But until we have access to more reliable information about visibility within the AI platforms themselves, we're cautious about adding estimated rankings and percentages to our regular reports.

We'd rather give you information we can explain and stand behind than fill your report with impressive-looking numbers that don't necessarily tell the whole story.

 ChatGPT Is Introducing Something New for Businesses

Here's where things get interesting!

OpenAI has introduced a new beta program that allows eligible businesses to claim and verify their business information directly within ChatGPT.

Think of it as another way for businesses to take ownership of how their information is presented online, although it works differently from familiar tools like Google Business Profile. Businesses participating in the program can manage certain details about their company, helping keep information about their services and online presence accurate and up to date.

But what really caught our attention was the introduction of business insights directly from ChatGPT.

The new platform is designed to provide information about business mentions, website clicks and the topics associated with how people discover businesses through ChatGPT. That's exciting because it represents a move toward information coming directly from the platform rather than relying entirely on estimates from outside reporting tools.

The program is still in beta and there are limitations to the information available. It's also too early to know exactly how useful the reporting will be for every type of business.

But it's an important development and one we're watching closely.


We've Already Claimed and Verified IA Creative

Of course, when we learned about this new program, we wanted to get our hands on it!

We've already successfully claimed and verified IA Creative through ChatGPT's new business platform, completed the required documentation and received approval. Now we're exploring the dashboard, testing the available features and waiting to see what information becomes available as the system develops.

This is something we take seriously when it comes to introducing new tools and services for our clients. We prefer to test things ourselves, understand how they work and figure out where they provide genuine value before recommending them to everyone else.

We're particularly interested in how businesses can manage their information within ChatGPT and what the new reporting tools could eventually tell us about their visibility. As the beta program develops and access becomes more widely available, we hope to help our clients claim and manage their own business listings too.

We're doing the learning now so we're better prepared to help you when the time comes.


Could AI Search Statistics Be Coming to Your Monthly Reports?

That's certainly our goal!

As ChatGPT and other AI platforms develop their business reporting tools, we're hoping to gain access to more meaningful information about how businesses are being discovered through AI search.

Eventually, we'd love to include useful insights about AI visibility, business mentions and website visits alongside the traditional SEO statistics we already provide.

We're also exploring how that information could work with our existing reporting systems. Once reliable data and practical integrations become available, we'll be looking at how to bring those insights into your monthly reports in a way that's easy to understand and genuinely useful.

There's still some work to be done before we get there, but we're encouraged by the direction things are heading. And we're already getting ready.


What Does This Mean for Your Business Right Now?

For now, there's no need to panic about AI search or feel like you're missing out because your monthly SEO report doesn't include AI visibility percentages.

The fundamentals of having a strong online presence still matter. A well-organized website, clear information about your services, useful content that answers customer questions and accurate business details across online platforms all help make your business easier to discover and understand.

These are already important parts of the website design, SEO, GEO, AEO and content strategies we develop for our clients.

As AI search continues to evolve, we'll keep exploring what's new, testing what works and finding ways to put those developments to work for our clients.

Have questions about AI search and what it means for your business? Get in touch. We'd love to hear from you!

Ian Atkinson

Ian is a digital systems architect, strategist, and creative technologist with over 20 years of experience building high-performance web platforms for real-world businesses. His work bridges the gap between creative design, technical engineering, and business strategy.

Next
Next

Your Holiday Marketing Should Start LONG Before the Holidays Do